Solution
If you are moving onto a new server and want to import your last server's configuration settings you will need to go through the NI VLM Getting Started Wizard to import your settings.
To launch the Getting Started Wizard you will need to reset NI VLM by going to
C:\ProgramData\National Instruments\Volume License Manager and deleting the following files:
- nilm.opt
- nivlm.dat
- nivlm.lic
After deleting these files, if you close and reopen NI VLM, the Getting Started Wizard should launch, allowing you to set up this new server and import your configuration settings.